A welcoming sidewalk bistro table beside a warmly lit downtown storefront, with simple dinner plates and a market tote holding autumn produce.

The Old Brit Corner on Alvarado Is a Family Restaurant Now, and Tuesday Evening Downtown Has Changed With It

  • November 12, 2026

For a quarter century, 444 Alvarado Street in Monterey was a pub. That changed on Oct. 23, 2026, when Benny Walker's quietly opened there, as Monterey County NOW reported. The owners call it "a family restaurant, food-forward, with a bar." It occupies the address the Britannia Arms held from 1999, and it runs on the same full liquor license.

The opening matters beyond one storefront. Alvarado already had the year-round Tuesday farmers market, and Gelato Pazzo Café opened at 482 Alvarado in early September. With Benny Walker's added, the street now has an early evening that starts at the market and ends with gelato, all within walking distance. Paris Bakery closed at the end of August, so a few parts of downtown are gone. Others now stay open into the evening.

What 444 Alvarado Was

The Britannia Arms opened in 1999. When Monterey Bay FC named it the club's official pub partner in July 2021, the club called the Brit a longtime place for local fans to watch international and domestic soccer. The partnership made it the home for away-match watch parties. The same announcement lists 24 beers on tap, a full bar, British-American food, breakfast seven days a week, weekend music and weekly karaoke.

The pub's run ended through its license. On Nov. 21, 2024, the California Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control revoked the Britannia Arms' liquor license, Monterey County NOW reported. NOW's coverage at the time said the revocation was stayed for 180 days so the license could be transferred, and the business went up for sale. Two weeks after the state acted, NOW reported that the pub was listed at $995,000. The paper described it as a popular spot for karaoke and soccer watch parties.

That stay explains why the corner looks the way it does today. The license moved to a new owner, so the address kept its full bar. The sale also brought in operators with a different idea of what the room should be.

Who Bought It, and Why the Room Feels Different

By May 31, 2025, KSBW reported that the license had been transferred and the location sold. The buyers were Susan and Ben Mosqueda, who run The Butter House in Seaside, together with partner Jeff Walters. Walters joined as partner and general manager, according to Edible Monterey Bay's June 2025 announcement. KSBW explained the name: it combines Benny's first name, Susan's maiden name and Walters's surname.

Edible's 2025 announcement hoped for an opening in early December 2025, with early 2026 as the more cautious estimate. The doors opened in late October 2026, almost a year after the hopeful date.

The plan the owners described to KSBW stayed the same through that wait. They wanted a family-friendly restaurant built around food, with a full bar, barbecue, specialty cocktails, and American cooking mixed with Filipino and Pacific Islander dishes. In Edible Monterey Bay's soft-opening report, Ben Mosqueda summed it up:

"A family restaurant, food-forward, with a bar."

Edible says the room keeps the bright, diner-style feel of The Butter House, but the focus moves from breakfast and brunch to lunch and dinner.

The Bar Came From a Fallen Sequoia

The wooden bar and the matching wall pieces at the back of the room come from a 1,700-year-old giant sequoia that fell after lightning, wildfire and wind on the Tule River Reservation near Porterville. Jeremy Vanderkraats of Old Growth Lumber Co. in Prunedale made the pieces. Edible reports that he first earned the tribe's trust, then traded an estimated $400,000 worth of signs and custom tables over five tribal council meetings. Old Growth Lumber is the sister business of Signs by Van, the multi-generation shop that made Cannery Row Company's name plates.

"It's a pretty historic thing we did," Vanderkraats told Edible.

Ben Mosqueda described the design inspiration to Edible as "the ocean, the mountain, the forest."

What's on the Soft-Opening Menu

Edible Monterey Bay printed these soft-opening prices on Oct. 27, 2026. Expect the menu to change as the restaurant settles in.

Dish What it is Price at soft open
Loaded Spam musubi Grilled Spam, rice and nori with pineapple furikake, chili garlic crunch, spicy Kewpie mayo and scallions $14
Grandma's lumpia Brought over from The Butter House in Seaside $7 for two
Deep-fried deviled eggs Panko and Parmesan crust, pork belly bits, paprika, capers, pickled red onion $12 for four halves
Stone fruit and burrata salad With prosciutto and fresh basil, served only at this location $18
Half-pound smash burger With fries $21
Hawaiian dinner Pineapple teriyaki chicken, kalua pulled pork, macaroni salad, white rice Not listed
BBQ dinner Ribs, marinated tri tip, mac 'n' cheese, coleslaw, cornbread with honey butter Not listed

Edible notes that the dinner plates run four to five components deep and work as shared plates for the middle of the table. A chopped cheese sandwich with griddled onions is the lighter alternative to the burger.

During the soft opening, the restaurant was open 4 to 8 p.m. daily. Edible reported that longer hours, 11 a.m. to 10:30 p.m., could start as soon as Nov. 11. Check the restaurant's own Facebook or Instagram page for current hours before you go. The Old Monterey Business Association directory lists it as a family restaurant and bar at 444 Alvarado.

Gelato at 482

The second new arrival on the street opened in early September. Edible Monterey Bay reported on Sept. 8 that Gelato Pazzo Café had just opened at 482 Alvarado St., in the former Twisted Roots shop. Owner-operator Carl Alasko previously owned il Vecchio in Pacific Grove. The café serves 27 gelato flavors alongside Italian-style focaccia, pasta, salads, charcuterie and coffee drinks.

With two new food businesses a short walk apart on Alvarado, the street now has dinner and dessert covered.

The Corner Downtown Lost

Paris Bakery closed just before the new openings arrived. Monterey County NOW reported that the bakery at 271 Bonifacio Place, open since 1985, ended its run on Sunday, Aug. 30. Master baker Jackie Jeget opened it and sold the family bakery in 2024 to a Los Angeles-based commercial kitchen operator. The closing was announced on social media.

The closure leaves downtown without a 41-year-old morning institution. This fall's openings fill the afternoon and evening. Mornings have nothing comparable yet.

A Tuesday Evening on Alvarado, in Order

The Old Monterey Farmers Market makes this sequence work. The market's official page says it runs year-round, rain or shine, every Tuesday on Alvarado Street between Del Monte and Pearl. From October through April it is open 4 to 7 p.m. The winter market starts at 4 p.m., the same time as Benny Walker's soft-opening dinner hours, so all three stops fit in one evening.

  1. Start at the market around 4 p.m. You have three winter hours on Alvarado before the market packs up at 7.
  2. Walk to 444 Alvarado for dinner. A Hawaiian or BBQ dinner plate is the shareable order for a table, and the deviled eggs work as a starter for the group.
  3. Finish at Gelato Pazzo Café, 482 Alvarado. With 27 flavors, the case has plenty of choices for a mixed group.

That route covers three addresses on one street: a year-round market, a dinner room built around a sequoia bar, and a gelato counter from a former Pacific Grove restaurateur.

If you host guests in a Monterey home and want their recommendations to stay as current as this block, Carmel Coast Realty can help. Schedule a local consultation to talk through keeping a guest-ready home in step with the town around it.

Work With Us

Carmel Coast Realty is a group of real estate experts making a positive impact on peoples' lives. Contact us today to start your home searching journey!

Follow Us On Instagram